Pizza in Bloomington: A Local Guide
Forget New York or Chicago — you can find world-class pizza right here in Bloomington. Whether you’re craving classic pepperoni and sausage, specialty vegetarian, gluten-free pizza, or gourmet made-from-scratch pies, there’s no shortage of Bloomington pizza places to satisfy your craving. Perfect for an easy dinner, movie night with the family, or a late-night snack when you’re out in the town.
Classic Bloomington Pizza Joints
Mother Bear’s frequently tops the list for the best pizza in Bloomington, earning multiple awards, including “Best Pizza in Indiana” from USA Today. Mother Bear’s serves up hearty, deep-dish–style pies in a quirky, wood-paneled interior that’s as iconic as the pizza itself.
For a taste of the outdoors, Trailhead Pizza offers a relaxed, neighborhood atmosphere where you can savor fresh pies and craft beer after a day of hiking or biking nearby.
New York–Style, Thin Crust, and Artisan Slices
If you’re craving something straight from the wood oven, Da Vinci Pizza & Pasta crafts Neapolitan-inspired pies that balance charred crusts with fresh ingredients — a little slice of Italy right on Kirkwood Avenue.
At Max’s Place, you can order to go or settle in for a brick-oven New York–style pie in a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere.
Vegan and Gluten-Free Friendly Spots
Bucceto’s Smiling Teeth is Bloomington’s go-to for vegetarian and vegan pizza, and almost any pie on their menu can be made gluten-free. Their vegan cheese and sausage are local favorites, and the gluten-free crust has just the right amount of chew.
Lennie’s is a laid-back brew pub with handcrafted pizzas, plenty of veggie and vegan options, and gluten-free dough. Pair your pie with a pint from their selection of Bloomington Brewing Company beers for the full local experience.
Fast, Casual, and Late-Night Pizza
Pizza X is Bloomington’s go-to for pizza delivery and late-night eats — their campus location stays open until 3 a.m.! With multiple spots around town, this family-owned chain has been serving students and locals since 1982.
For something quick and no-frills, Rockit’s Famous Pizza serves up New York–style slices perfect for grabbing a bite between music venues or brewery stops.
Pizza for Pickup or Delivery
Sometimes the perfect pizza night means staying in — and Bloomington’s best carryout and pizza delivery spots make it easy to enjoy a slice from the comfort of home. Nearly every restaurant on this list offers pickup and delivery, many with easy online ordering.
Aver's Pizza has five signature pies that are multi-award winners — the Cream & Crimson, Parthenon, Beckon Desire, Lambda Gyro Pi, and Chicken Bacon Ranch. Aver's offers not only mouth-watering signature pies with unique toppings, but also vegan options and great specials.
At Baldy’s Pizza, locals rave about the hand-tossed crust, hearty toppings, and generous portions. It’s the kind of place where every pizza feels homemade — ideal for takeout when you want something comforting and classic. Their quick, friendly service makes Baldy’s a favorite for families and busy weeknights.
DeAngelo’s offers wood-fired pizzas, pasta, and salads, available for dine-in or pickup. The thin, flavorful crust and gourmet toppings make it an excellent option for a cozy night in or a low-key dinner date at home.
Plan Your Perfect Pizza Night
No matter your taste: classic, creative, or plant-based, Bloomington’s pizza scene is full of flavor and personality. Explore more Bloomington pizza places or check out our Best Pizza in Bloomington roundup for more delicious inspiration.
