November 1 signifies two things: the official arrival of the holidays, and peak pie season. Whether you're simply craving the classic holiday treat or you're looking to pre-order pies for your Thanksgiving spread, these beloved Bloomington restaurants and bakeries will satisfy all of your sweet & savory pie needs.
This blog will continue to be updated as more information becomes available.
Bloomingfoods
Bloomingfoods, Bloomington's co-op grocery store, is offering pumpkin pie, apple pie, and pecan pie for the holiday season.
Cloverleaf
Cloverleaf offers two amazing pies. They are offering cream pie slices for $3.99 or whole pies for $10.99 with coconut, chocolate, peanut butter, and banana. They also offer strawberry pie slices for $3.99 or the whole pie for $14.49. Grab yourself a cobbler slice for $3.50 while you are there as well!
Crumble
Crumble is accepting holiday pies orders, you need to place your order at least 2 business days before you'd like to pick it up. They're offering pumpkin, pecan, apple, and apple cranberry for $25 each and chocolate pecan, blueberry, and key lime pies are $28 each. Email laura@crumblecoffee.com to place your order.
Hive
Hive is offering three flavors of pie this season: a pumpkin pie, chocolate pie, and their Hive Pie, which is a Buttermilk Pie (think Sugar Cream Pie with more depth of flavor and a Creme Brulée style top). Pies are available for order starting after Halloween. Place your order by calling 812-287-7405.
Jenny's Baking Co
Jenny's Baking Co, a brand new bakery that opened in October 2024, is offering a variety of pies, including salted caramel apple pie, pumpkin pie, and pecan pie. Orders can be placed online or by emailing jennysbakingco@gmail.com.
Piccoli Dolci
Piccoli Dolci will have a variety of tarts including lemon, pear vanilla, raspberry crostata, apricot crostata, blueberry vanilla, and an apple strudel. Orders can be made online.
Raven's Nest Pastries
Raven's Nest Pastries is taking Thanksgiving orders for pumpkin, apple, sweet potato, and maple pecan pies for $35. To order your pie, text 812-369-1077.
Two Sticks Bakery
Two Sticks Bakery is offering a variety of flavors for the holidays and pre-orders will begin after Halloween. Orders can be made in-person or over the phone.
Craving other seasonal treats? Check out these blogs:
