November 1 signifies two things: the official arrival of the holidays, and peak pie season. Whether you're simply craving the classic holiday treat or you're looking to pre-order pies for your Thanksgiving spread, these beloved Bloomington restaurants and bakeries will satisfy all of your sweet & savory pie needs.

This blog will continue to be updated as more information becomes available.



Bloomingfoods, Bloomington's co-op grocery store, is offering nine-inch pumpkin, apple, and pecan pies this season. Place a Thanksgiving pre-order now to pick up the week of the holiday, or stop in one of their locations to purchase your desired pie(s) at their Customer Service desk. Pre-orders are being accepted through Nov. 6th.


Hive is offering three flavors of pie this season:  a pumpkin pie, chocolate brownie pie, and their Hive Pie, which is a Buttermilk Pie (think Sugar Cream Pie with more depth of flavor and a Creme Brulée style top). Place your order for a whole pie by November 14 to ensure availability. Orders can be picked up November 21-23 by appointment during regular business hours. Place your order by calling 812-287-7405 or emailing Hive will be closed on Thanksgiving.


Crumble & Crumble at Renwick are accepting holiday pies orders, you need to place your order at least 2 business days before you'd like to pick it up. They're offering pecan, pumpkin, apple, and cranberry apple for $25 each, Chocolate pecan, blueberry, and key lime pies are $30 each.

Two Sticks Bakery

Pie orders for Two Sticks Bakery start on Thursday, November 2 and will be available for pick up on Wednesday, November 22 only. The pre-order flavors are apple crumb, bourbon pecan, and classic pumpkin. All pies are made with an all butter crust and cost $30.00. Orders can be made in-person or over the phone with payment being due at the time of ordering. The bakery case will be full of pies on Wednesday, November 22 for those who do not pre-order. 


Craving other seasonal treats? Check out these blogs: